In this article, we will compare electric vs propane smokers to help you choose the right one for your needs. We tested and researched several models to identify the best options for both types of smokers. Our top pick is the EAST OAK 30″ Digital Electric Smoker.
Smoking meat can be a delicious and satisfying way to cook, but it can also be a time-consuming and labor-intensive process. Fortunately, electric and propane smokers offer a convenient and efficient way to smoke meat at home.
Electric smokers are powered by electricity and use heating elements to generate smoke. They are easy to use and require minimal maintenance, making them a popular choice for beginners.
Propane smokers, on the other hand, use propane gas to heat up wood chips and create smoke. They offer more control over temperature and smoke production, making them a favorite among experienced smokers.
When choosing between electric and propane smokers, it is essential to consider factors such as size, temperature range, and ease of use.
The size of the smoker will determine how much meat you can smoke at once, while the temperature range will affect the types of meat and smoking techniques you can use. Ease of use is also important, as some smokers require more attention and maintenance than others.
Electric vs Propane Smokers
When it comes to smoking meat, two popular options are electric and propane smokers. Electric smokers are known for their ease of use and convenience, while propane smokers are often preferred for their portability and ability to reach higher temperatures.
In this roundup, we will be showcasing the best electric and propane smokers on the market to help you make an informed decision on which type of smoker is right for you.
1. EAST OAK 30″ Digital Electric Smoker
If you’re looking for an electric smoker that is easy to use and provides excellent smoked flavor, the EAST OAK 30″ Digital Electric Smoker is a great option.
With its spacious cooking area, precise temperature control, and durable construction, this smoker is perfect for both beginners and experienced smokers.
Pros
- The side wood chip loader makes it easy to add wood chips without opening the door, which helps to maintain the heat and smoke inside the smoker.
- The bottom heating tube provides even and consistent smoke, resulting in a delicious smoked flavor every time.
- The large cooking space and four removable racks allow you to cook a variety of meats for small or large groups.
Cons
- Some users have reported issues with the door seal, which can let smoke escape and affect the cooking temperature.
- The smoker is quite heavy and may be difficult to move around, especially if you need to move it up or down stairs.
- The digital controls can be a bit confusing at first, and it may take some time to get used to the various settings.
The EAST OAK 30″ Digital Electric Smoker is a great choice for anyone who wants to enjoy delicious smoked meats without the hassle of traditional smoking methods.
The side wood chip loader and bottom heating tube make it easy to achieve consistent smoke and heat, while the large cooking space and four removable racks allow you to cook a variety of meats for small or large groups.
However, some users have reported issues with the door seal and the digital controls can be a bit confusing at first. Overall, this is a great smoker for anyone who wants to enjoy the delicious flavor of smoked meats without the hassle of traditional smoking methods.
2. Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical Propane Smoker
If you’re looking for a propane smoker that’s easy to use and provides ample smoking space, the Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical Propane Smoker is a great option.
Pros
- The 5.45 square feet of interior space provides plenty of room to smoke a variety of meats and vegetables.
- The adjustable gas supply gives you control over the amount of heat, and the built-in thermometer allows for easy monitoring of the internal temperature.
- The four removable stainless steel shelves make it easy to smoke whole birds or large cuts of meat, and they’re dishwasher safe for easy cleanup.
Cons
- Some users have reported that the door seal isn’t as tight as they would like, which can lead to a loss of smoke and heat.
- The smoker requires wood chips when grilling, which can be an added expense.
- The propane tank isn’t included, so you’ll need to purchase that separately.
The Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical Propane Smoker is a great option for those who want a propane smoker that’s easy to use and provides ample smoking space.
With its adjustable gas supply and built-in thermometer, you’ll be able to control the temperature and monitor the internal temperature with ease.
The four removable stainless steel shelves make it easy to smoke whole birds or large cuts of meat, and they’re dishwasher safe for easy cleanup. However, some users have reported that the door seal isn’t as tight as they would like, which can lead to a loss of smoke and heat.
Additionally, the smoker requires wood chips when grilling, which can be an added expense (check out the Weber Q1200 vs Q2200 review to find out the difference between the grills).
Overall, if you’re looking for a reliable and easy-to-use propane smoker, the Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical Propane Smoker is a great choice.
3. Masterbuilt MB20071117 Digital Electric Smoker
If you’re looking for an electric smoker that’s easy to use and produces delicious smoked meats, the Masterbuilt MB20071117 Digital Electric Smoker is a great option.
Pros
- The vertical design of this smoker allows for 710 square inches of cooking space, making it perfect for cooking large cuts of meat or smoking multiple items at once.
- The digital control panel makes it easy to set and monitor the temperature of the smoker, ensuring consistent cooking results every time.
- The electric fuel source means you won’t have to worry about running out of propane or charcoal, and the smoker produces minimal smoke, making it ideal for use in areas where traditional smokers may not be allowed.
Cons
- Some users have reported issues with the heating element burning out after a few years of use.
- The lack of a stand or legs means the smoker must be placed on a sturdy surface, which may not be ideal for all users.
- The temperature control can be a bit finicky, requiring some trial and error to get the hang of.
Overall, the Masterbuilt MB20071117 Digital Electric Smoker is a great choice for those looking for an easy-to-use smoker that produces delicious results.
With its large cooking space, digital control panel, and electric fuel source, this smoker is sure to be a hit at your next barbecue.
4. Pit Boss Grills PBV3G1 Vertical Smoker Hammertone
This Pit Boss Grills PBV3G1 Vertical Smoker is a great choice for those who want to smoke their food with propane.
Pros
- The dual valve and dual stainless steel burner system allow for precise temperature control.
- The 100°F – 320°F temperature range provides versatility in cooking different types of food.
- The 720-square-inch cooking area is large enough to smoke food for a big family gathering.
Cons
- The external wood chip and ash removal feature can be messy to clean up after use.
- The high-temperature door seal may not be as tight as expected, leading to some heat loss.
- The 12,500 BTU output may not be enough for some users who want to smoke food quickly.
This smoker is easy to assemble and use, with clear instructions provided. The four porcelain-coated cooking grids are durable and easy to clean, and the front access grease drawer makes cleaning up after use a breeze.
The large viewing window with a professional heat indicator allows for easy monitoring of the food being smoked without opening the door and letting out heat and smoke.
Users have reported that this smoker produces great-tasting food and is a good value for the price. Some have also noted that the propane tank is not included with the purchase and must be bought separately.
Overall, the Pit Boss Grills PBV3G1 Vertical Smoker is a solid choice for those who want to smoke their food with propane.
5. Masterbuilt MB20070122 Digital Electric Smoker
If you’re looking for a smoker that is easy to use and produces succulent smoked meats with minimal effort, the Masterbuilt MB20070122 Digital Electric Smoker with Window and Legs may be the right choice for you.
Pros
- The digital control board allows for easy temperature and time settings up to 275°F, making it simple to achieve the perfect smoke.
- The patented side woodchip loader allows for continuous wood-fired smoked flavor without opening the smoker door, resulting in enhanced flavors and an improved cooking process.
- The vertical design of the smoker conserves space while optimizing flavor infusion, making it ideal for those with limited outdoor space.
Cons
- The door seal may leak, causing residue to spill out of the smoker onto the floor.
- The smoker may throw error codes in cold weather, making it difficult to use in certain climates.
- The exterior of the smoker may become damaged during shipping, leading to frustration for the buyer.
The Masterbuilt MB20070122 Digital Electric Smoker is a great option for those looking for an easy-to-use smoker that produces delicious, flavorful meat.
The digital control board makes it simple to set the temperature and time, while the patented side woodchip loader allows for continuous wood-fired smoked flavor without opening the door.
The vertical design of the smoker conserves space while optimizing flavor infusion, making it ideal for those with limited outdoor space.
However, the door seal may leak, causing residue to spill out of the smoker onto the floor. Additionally, the smoker may throw error codes in cold weather, making it difficult to use in certain climates.
Finally, the exterior of the smoker may become damaged during shipping, leading to frustration for the buyer.
Overall, the Masterbuilt MB20070122 Digital Electric Smoker is a solid choice for those looking for an easy-to-use smoker that produces delicious, flavorful meat.
You might also be interested in checking out the comparison guide for heater electric vs propane.
Buying Guide
When choosing between an electric and propane smoker, there are a few key features to consider to ensure you get the best product for your needs.
Fuel Source
The first decision to make is whether to go with an electric or propane smoker. Electric smokers are generally easier to use and require less maintenance, but propane smokers offer greater control over temperature and a more traditional smoking experience.
Capacity
Consider the size of the smoker and whether it will be able to accommodate the amount of food you plan to smoke. Smokers come in a range of sizes, from small portable models to large commercial units.
Temperature Range
Temperature range is an important factor to consider, as it will determine what types of food you can smoke. Look for a smoker with a wide temperature range and the ability to maintain consistent temperatures.
Ease of Use
Look for a smoker that is easy to use and maintain. Features like digital controls, automatic shut-off, and removable racks make for a more user-friendly experience.
Price
Price is always a consideration, but don’t sacrifice quality for a lower price tag. Look for a smoker with all the features you need, even if it means spending a little more.
By considering these factors, you can choose the best electric or propane smoker for your needs and enjoy delicious smoked meats and vegetables in the comfort of your own home.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the main differences in flavor between electric and propane smokers?
The main difference in flavor between electric and propane smokers is the type of fuel used. Propane smokers use propane gas to heat up the wood chips, while electric smokers use electricity to heat up the wood chips.
The type of wood chips used can also affect the flavor of the food. Some people believe that propane smokers produce a more authentic smoky flavor, while others argue that electric smokers produce a cleaner flavor.
How do maintenance requirements compare for electric versus propane smokers?
Electric smokers require less maintenance than propane smokers as they have fewer parts that need to be cleaned and maintained. Propane smokers have more moving parts, such as the propane tank, regulator, and burner, that require regular cleaning and maintenance.
Electric smokers also do not produce as much smoke residue as propane smokers, which means they require less cleaning.
Which type of smoker is more cost-effective in the long run, electric or propane?
Electric smokers are generally more cost-effective in the long run as they use less fuel and have lower maintenance requirements. Propane smokers require regular refilling of the propane tank, which can be expensive over time.
Electric smokers also have a longer lifespan than propane smokers, which means they do not need to be replaced as often.
What are the safety considerations when choosing between an electric and a propane smoker?
When choosing between an electric and a propane smoker, safety considerations include the risk of fire and carbon monoxide poisoning.
Propane smokers have a higher risk of fire due to the open flame, while electric smokers do not have an open flame and are less likely to cause a fire.
Carbon monoxide poisoning can occur if the smoker is not properly ventilated, so it is important to ensure that the smoker is used in a well-ventilated area.
Can electric smokers achieve a true smoke ring as well as propane smokers?
Electric smokers can achieve a true smoke ring, but it may not be as pronounced as propane smokers. The smoke ring is caused by the interaction of nitrogen oxides and myoglobin in the meat, which occurs when the meat is exposed to wood smoke.
Electric smokers produce less smoke than propane smokers, which means the smoke ring may not be as prominent.
How do electric and propane smokers perform in different weather conditions?
Electric smokers perform well in all weather conditions as they are not affected by the weather. Propane smokers, on the other hand, can be affected by cold weather as the propane gas may not vaporize properly in cold temperatures.
This can cause the burner to malfunction and affect the cooking temperature. It is important to keep the propane tank warm in cold weather to prevent this from happening.